Student Loan vs Scholarship: How are They Different?

Understanding how a student loan is different from a scholarship is crucial for making informed decisions about financing your education. The fundamental distinction is straightforward but profound: loans must be repaid with interest, while scholarships are gift aid that doesn't require repayment. This difference has far-reaching implications for your financial future.

This article provides a detailed comparison of both funding options, including their eligibility requirements, application processes, advantages, and disadvantages, with special attention to the challenges faced by transfer students. By understanding these differences, you can develop strategies to minimize student debt and maximize free financial aid opportunities throughout your entire college journey.

‍

What Are Student Loans?

Student loans are borrowed money that must be repaid with interest, typically after graduation. They represent a common financing option when personal savings and gift aid are insufficient to cover educational expenses. Taking out a student loan creates a legal obligation to repay the borrowed amount plus interest according to specific terms and conditions.

Student loans can come from federal government programs or private financial institutions, each with different terms, interest rates, and repayment options. For community college students, loans may become increasingly important later in their academic journey, particularly when other forms of aid have been exhausted.

While loans provide immediate access to funds for education, they represent a long-term financial commitment that can impact post-graduation finances for years or even decades. This makes understanding the different types of loans and their implications essential before borrowing.

Federal Student Loans

Federal student loans are offered by the U.S. Department of Education and typically provide more favorable terms than private loans. The main types include:

1. Direct Subsidized Loans: Available to undergraduate students with demonstrated financial need. The government pays the interest while you're in school at least half-time, during grace periods, and during deferment periods.
2. Direct Unsubsidized Loans: Available to undergraduate and graduate students regardless of financial need. Interest accrues from the time the loan is disbursed, even while you're in school.
3. Direct PLUS Loans: Available to graduate students and parents of dependent undergraduate students. These loans require a credit check and have higher interest rates than other federal student loans.
4. Perkins Loans: While this program has been discontinued for new loans, some students may still be repaying these loans, which were available to students with exceptional financial need.

Federal loans offer several advantages, including fixed interest rates, income-driven repayment plans, deferment options, and potential loan forgiveness programs. They typically don't require credit checks (except for PLUS loans) or cosigners, making them more accessible to students without established credit histories or family financial support.

This accessibility is particularly important for community college students, many of whom are first-generation college students without family members who can serve as cosigners or help navigate the financial aid process. The application process for federal loans is through the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA), and loan amounts are determined based on financial need and cost of attendance.

While completing the FAFSA can be challenging, especially for students doing it independently, resources are available through college financial aid offices to help students through the process. Students planning to transfer from community college to a university should be particularly diligent about completing the FAFSA each year to maintain access to federal aid.

Private Student Loans

Private student loans are offered by banks, credit unions, and other financial institutions rather than the federal government. These loans typically require credit checks and often a cosigner for students with limited credit history. For many community college students, particularly first-generation students, finding a qualified cosigner can be challenging due to limited family financial resources or lack of established credit within their support network.

Private loans generally have higher interest rates than federal loans, may offer variable rather than fixed rates, and provide fewer protections and flexible repayment options. However, private loans can serve as a crucial bridge for students who have exhausted federal aid options or need additional funding to complete their degrees.

When comparing private lenders, students should look for competitive rates, flexible repayment options, and additional support services. For example, Ascent Funding offers competitive fixed APRs, covers up to 100% of school-certified costs, and allows students to check their rate in under 3 minutes without impacting their credit score. What sets Ascent apart is their AscentUP program, which provides borrowers with career support, financial wellness education, and access to paid remote internship opportunities - benefits that extend beyond traditional lending. Notably, Ascent also offers options for students without cosigners, which can be particularly valuable for community college students who may not have family members available to cosign loans.

Other private loan providers include Citizens Bank, College Ave, LendKey, Sallie Mae, and CommonBond, with terms and conditions varying significantly between lenders. Private loans should generally be considered only after federal loan options have been exhausted. The application process varies by lender but typically involves submitting financial information and academic details.

Loan Repayment Considerations

For most federal student loans, repayment typically begins six months after graduation, leaving school, or dropping below half-time enrollment. Standard repayment periods range from 10 to 25 years, depending on the repayment plan selected.

Federal loans offer various repayment options, including:

1. Standard Repayment Plan: Fixed monthly payments over 10 years
2. Graduated Repayment Plan: Payments start low and increase every two years
3. Extended Repayment Plan: Payments spread over up to 25 years
4. Income-Driven Repayment Plans: Monthly payments based on income and family size

Income-driven repayment plans can be particularly helpful for recent graduates with lower starting salaries, as they adjust monthly payments based on income and family size. These plans include Income-Based Repayment (IBR), Pay As You Earn (PAYE), Revised Pay As You Earn (REPAYE), and Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR).

Federal loans also offer forgiveness programs, including Public Service Loan Forgiveness for those working in qualifying public service jobs and Teacher Loan Forgiveness for eligible teachers. These programs can significantly reduce loan burdens for those in qualifying professions.

The consequences of loan default are severe and can include damage to credit scores, wage garnishment, and tax refund interception. To avoid these outcomes, borrowers should stay informed about their loans, keep accurate records, and communicate with loan servicers if they encounter difficulty making payments.

Students transferring to an out of state university should be particularly mindful of how increased tuition costs might affect their total loan burden and future repayment obligations.

‍

What Are Scholarships?

Scholarships are financial awards that do not require repayment, typically based on merit, talent, demographic characteristics, or field of study. Unlike loans, scholarships represent "free money" for education that can significantly reduce the need for borrowing.

Scholarships can come from various sources, including colleges and universities, private organizations, corporations, professional associations, community groups, and foundations. They create no future financial obligation, though they may have requirements for maintaining eligibility, such as minimum GPA standards or participation in specific activities.

For community college students planning to transfer, scholarships can be particularly important as they may face funding gaps when other forms of aid are no longer available. Scholarship amounts vary widely, ranging from small one-time awards to full-ride packages covering tuition, fees, books, and living expenses.

Types of Scholarships

Scholarships come in many forms, each with different eligibility criteria and application requirements:

1. Academic Merit Scholarships: Based on GPA, test scores, and academic achievements. These are often offered by universities to attract high-performing students, including transfer students with strong community college records.
2. Athletic Scholarships: Awarded to students with exceptional abilities in sports. These are typically offered by NCAA and NAIA institutions.
3. Field-Specific Scholarships: Targeted at students pursuing particular majors or career paths. Professional organizations, businesses, and foundations often offer these to encourage students to enter specific fields.
4. Demographic-Specific Scholarships: Based on factors like ethnicity, gender, religion, or LGBTQ+ identity. Many scholarships specifically target first-generation college students, which many community college students qualify for.
5. Need-Based Scholarships: Consider financial circumstances and are designed to help students with limited financial resources.
6. Competition-Based Scholarships: Awarded through essays, projects, or performances that demonstrate particular skills or knowledge.
7. Transfer-Specific Scholarships: Offered by 4-year universities specifically to attract community college students. These can be particularly valuable for students transferring from community college to a private university or other 4-year institutions.

Students should explore all categories for which they might qualify, as scholarship opportunities exist for diverse talents, backgrounds, and interests. Many students qualify for multiple scholarship types, so casting a wide net in applications is advisable.

Finding and Applying for Scholarships

The scholarship search and application process requires diligence and organization. Students can find scholarship opportunities through various resources:

1. Online Scholarship Databases: Websites like Fastweb, Scholarships.com, and the College Board's BigFuture
2. High School Guidance Offices: Resources for graduating seniors
3. College Financial Aid Offices: Information on institutional scholarships
4. Community Foundations: Local scholarships for residents
5. Professional Organizations: Field-specific opportunities

For community college students planning to transfer, platforms like EdVisorly can be particularly valuable, as they help students discover transfer-friendly universities and connect directly with admissions teams to learn about institution-specific scholarship opportunities. EdVisorly's transfer planning tools also help students understand how their credits will transfer, which can be crucial for maintaining scholarship eligibility that depends on academic progress and completing degrees within expected timeframes.

Typical scholarship applications include:

• Application forms
• Essays
• Recommendation letters
• Transcripts
• Financial information

To create compelling scholarship applications, students should:

• Follow instructions precisely
• Meet all deadlines
• Tailor applications to specific scholarships
• Proofread carefully
• Highlight unique qualities and experiences

For students navigating this process without family support, college financial aid offices and community college transfer counselors can provide valuable assistance with scholarship applications. Many scholarship deadlines occur up to a year before college enrollment, so planning ahead is essential.

Students should apply for multiple scholarships to maximize opportunities. Even smaller, less competitive scholarships can add up to significant funding. For students taking general education courses at community college, researching scholarships early in their academic journey can help them prepare stronger applications when they're ready to transfer.

Scholarship Renewal and Maintenance

Many scholarships are not one-time awards but renewable for multiple years if certain conditions are met. Common scholarship maintenance requirements include:

• Maintaining a minimum GPA (often 2.5-3.0)
• Completing a specific number of credit hours each semester
• Remaining in a particular major
• Participating in certain activities or programs

For transfer students, understanding how transferring between institutions might affect scholarship eligibility is crucial. Students should investigate whether scholarships from their community college can transfer with them or if they'll need to apply for new scholarships at their destination university.

Credit transfer issues can impact progress toward degree completion, which may affect scholarship eligibility that depends on timely progress. Students should work with advisors to ensure they're taking the right classes in community college to transfer and maintain scholarship eligibility.

Failing to meet scholarship requirements may result in probationary periods or loss of funding. Students facing challenges that might affect their eligibility should proactively communicate with scholarship providers, as some offer flexibility in extenuating circumstances.

Understanding renewal requirements before accepting scholarships and developing academic plans that support maintaining eligibility throughout college is essential for long-term financial planning.

‍

Key Differences Between Student Loans and Scholarships

When examining how is a student loan different from a scholarship, several key distinctions emerge:

Repayment Obligations:

• Loans: Must be repaid with interest, creating a long-term financial obligation
• Scholarships: Require no repayment, representing true gift aid

Eligibility Criteria:

• Loans: Generally available to all students, though terms may vary based on need or credit
• Scholarships: Typically competitive and awarded based on specific criteria like merit, talent, or demographics

Application Process:

• Federal Loans: Require FAFSA completion
• Private Loans: Involve credit applications and often require cosigners
• Scholarships: Often require essays, recommendation letters, and other materials demonstrating qualifications

Long-Term Financial Impact:

• Loans: Create future financial burdens that can affect post-graduation financial health
• Scholarships: Provide immediate financial relief without future obligations

Availability:

• Loans: Generally more accessible but come with financial costs
• Scholarships: More competitive but offer better financial value

For community college students, federal loans may not require cosigners, while private loans often do, which can create barriers for students without family support. This makes federal aid and scholarships particularly important for students with limited financial resources or family backing.

Financial Impact Comparison

The long-term financial differences between using loans versus scholarships to finance education are substantial. Consider this example:

A student borrowing $20,000 in federal student loans at 5% interest with a standard 10-year repayment plan would pay approximately $25,500 total, including $5,500 in interest. Monthly payments would be about $212.

In contrast, receiving $20,000 in scholarships would require no repayment, saving the student that entire $5,500 in interest and freeing up $212 monthly in their post-graduation budget for other financial goals.

The opportunity costs associated with loan repayment can include:

• Delayed homeownership
• Reduced retirement savings
• Limited ability to save for other goals
• Restricted career choices based on salary requirements
• Delayed family formation

For community college students who may have limited family financial support, minimizing debt burden through scholarships can provide greater financial stability after graduation. This is particularly important for students who transfer from community college to a 4-year university and may face higher costs in their final years of education.

When to Choose Loans vs. Scholarships

While scholarships are always preferable from a financial perspective, loans may be necessary to fill funding gaps, particularly for students who have exhausted other forms of financial aid. This is especially relevant for community college students who may face funding gaps after exhausting federal grant eligibility but are close to completing their degrees.

Reasonable loan amounts might be appropriate in scenarios such as:

• Funding education that leads to high-paying careers
• When the alternative would be delaying education
• When loan amounts are proportional to expected post-graduation income

Financial experts often recommend limiting total student loan borrowing to no more than the expected first-year salary in your chosen field. This guideline helps ensure that repayment will be manageable on an entry-level salary.

Students should exhaust scholarship opportunities before turning to loans and continue applying for scholarships throughout college, not just before freshman year. Strategies for minimizing loan amounts include:

• Attending less expensive institutions
• Starting at community colleges
• Working part-time during school
• Taking advantage of employer tuition assistance
• Accelerating degree completion when possible

For students who need to transfer to an online university for flexibility or cost reasons, researching scholarship opportunities specifically for online learners can help reduce reliance on loans.

‍

What Are Grants?

Grants represent a third major category of financial aid or gift aid that, like scholarships, do not require repayment. Grants are typically need-based financial assistance provided by federal and state governments, colleges, and private organizations.

Major federal grant programs include:

1. Pell Grants: The largest federal grant program for undergraduate students with financial need
2. Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grants (FSEOG): Additional aid for students with exceptional financial need
3. TEACH Grants: For students planning to become teachers in high-need fields in low-income areas
4. Iraq and Afghanistan Service Grants: For students whose parent or guardian died as a result of military service in Iraq or Afghanistan

For community college students, it's important to understand that Pell Grants have a lifetime limit of 6 full-time semesters (or equivalent). This limitation can create funding gaps later in their academic journey, especially for transfer students who may take longer to complete their degrees due to credit transfer issues or other factors. When Pell Grant eligibility is exhausted, students may need to explore alternative funding sources, including scholarships and loans, to complete their degrees.

State grant programs vary by location but often provide significant funding for in-state students. Many states have specific grants for community college students or transfer students. Institutional grants offered directly by colleges and universities may also be available based on financial need or other criteria.

While grants and scholarships are both forms of gift aid, grants are primarily awarded based on financial need rather than merit or other criteria. The application process for most grants begins with completing the FAFSA, which is essential for accessing federal and many state grant programs.

For students who need assistance completing the FAFSA due to language barriers or lack of family support, college financial aid offices provide resources and assistance. Students who go to community college after high school should make FAFSA completion an annual priority to maintain access to grant funding.

‍

How to Create a Financial Aid Strategy

Developing a strategic approach to combining various funding sources throughout the entire college journey is essential for minimizing debt while maximizing educational opportunities. A typical financial aid package includes a combination of scholarships, grants, loans, and possibly work-study.

A sequential approach to seeking funding is recommended:

1. Apply for scholarships and grants (free money)
2. Consider work-study opportunities (earned money)
3. Turn to federal loans if needed (lowest-cost borrowed money)
4. Consider private loans as a last resort (higher-cost borrowed money)

For community college students, planning for potential funding changes throughout their academic journey is particularly important, as federal grant eligibility may be exhausted before degree completion. Students should continuously seek scholarship opportunities, not just during their initial enrollment, as transfer scholarships and upper-level scholarships may become available.

Key financial aid deadlines include:

• FAFSA: Available October 1 for the following academic year
• Institutional aid: Varies by college, often early spring
• Major scholarship programs: Typically 6-12 months before funds are needed

When circumstances warrant, students can appeal financial aid offers, particularly if their financial situation has changed since filing the FAFSA. This process varies by institution but typically involves submitting documentation of changed circumstances.

When comparing financial aid packages from different institutions, students should look beyond the total amount to understand the breakdown between gift aid and loans. A package with more gift aid and less loan funding is generally preferable, even if the total amount is smaller.

For transfer students, platforms like EdVisorly can help in discovering universities with strong transfer support and financial aid opportunities. EdVisorly's tools can assist students in understanding how their credits will transfer and identifying institutions that offer strong financial support for transfer students.

To evaluate the true cost of attendance, students should calculate: 

Total Cost of Attendance - Gift Aid = Net Cost 

This net cost represents the amount that must be covered through personal funds, work, or loans.

‍

Take Control of Your Transfer Journey

Ready to explore your transfer options and discover universities with strong financial aid opportunities for transfer students? Download the EdVisorly app today to connect directly with admissions teams, plan your transfer path, and find the financial support you need to achieve your educational goals without excessive debt.

‍